Ten years after the UK embarked on a rushed public vote that split the country and triggered turmoil, a advisory emerges from beyond the Irish Sea: it might repeat.
The government and electorate sleepwalked into Brexit and the same could occur with a referendum on a unified Ireland, initiating disturbances for which nobody is prepared.
That represents the warning from two leading commentators from both sides of the Irish border who have joined forces to scrutinise the benefits and drawbacks of Northern Ireland leaving the UK to create a new state with the Republic of Ireland.
Political Structures Unprepared
Fintan O’Toole and Sam McBride, have concluded that the government bodies in Ireland and Britain are woefully ill-prepared for a potentially contentious and seismic public vote.
"The crucial insight of Brexit hasn't been learned, which is that developments can arise suddenly and can gather momentum very quickly," the commentator stated. "I would suggest that the governmental framework of our islands remains highly fragile."
New Title Seeks to Stir Debate
The pair have studied the governmental, economic and cultural arguments for any governmental shift in a book, Examining Irish Unification, released by the Irish Royal Irish Academy.
They aim to encourage dialogue on the issue with a series of speaking events that will take them to Westminster early next month.
"What troubles everybody, or ought to concern everybody, is the Brexit referendum of 2016," said O’Toole.
"We do not want a national vote on a thumbs up-thumbs down, vague proposition whose results have not been spelled out because then you land with an extremely split population where people who have lost are resistant to defeat and the people who have won don't know precisely what it is that they have won."
Legal Framework
Under the Good Friday agreement, the Northern Ireland secretary of state must arrange a referendum on Irish unification if it is indicated that a most voters would vote in favour.
Sinn Féin and other nationalists say that moment is approaching, and a group called Ireland’s Future has rallied support, but both governments and pro-UK factions minimise the possibility, leaving it unclear whether or when there might be a referendum.
Lack of Substantive Discussion
Partisan language for and against unification has masked the absence of informed dialogue, said McBride.
"People tend to be for or against the idea but the concrete planning which might go beyond that to make it possible is mostly absent. A lot has gone on in scholarly circles but scarcely any politicians or activists seek to involve themselves with even the basics. For instance, what sort of state should be desired? Centralised? Federal?"
Book's Approach
In the volume, neither author endorses unification or the current situation. Each composes two pieces that aim for impartiality in detailing the rationale for a unified Ireland and the case against, marshalling economic and social figures, past examples and constitutional models.
Arguments encompass national emblems, levies, healthcare systems, elderly benefits, sovereign debt obligations and the danger of unionist unrest. The objective is to educate and provoke dialogue.
"There is significant curiosity in the subject but there hasn't quite been a discussion," commented O’Toole. "Debate suggests an acceptance of the notion that there could be reasonable perspectives on each side."
Simultaneous Plebiscites
A public vote in Northern Ireland would also trigger one in the republic, where citizens claim they prefer unity but reject greater financial contributions or adopting a alternative symbol to acknowledge pro-UK communities' British identity.
"Policymakers in Ireland does need to determine what the offer from Irish nationalism is beyond just saying: 'We desire a united Ireland and we welcome you'," stated the commentator.
Likelihood of Referendum
The journalist believes a national vote in his generation is likely and that it could happen suddenly. "You could have just a reckless or a ill-advised or a feckless official who states: 'We should proceed and get it out of the way.'"
Each of the pro-unification advocates and unionists have plausible, legitimate perspectives, he commented. "Somebody will succeed here and somebody will eventually not succeed but all factions has got something to learn from the opposing viewpoints."
Appeal for More Extensive Discussion
Westminster should participate in the discussion, stated O’Toole. "This concerns your state. It is a British question equally as it is an Irish question."